Investors often turn to recommendations made by Wall Street analysts before making a Buy, Sell, or Hold decision about a stock. While media reports about rating changes by these brokerage-firm employed (or sell-side) analysts often affect a stock's price, do they really matter?Let's take a look at what these Wall Street heavyweights have to say about Costco (COST) before we discuss the reliability of brokerage recommendations and how to use them to your advantage.Costco currently has an average brokerage re ...

Costco's Business Strategy - Costco attracts members with low-cost items like hot dogs and bananas, while encouraging bulk purchases of high-dollar products [1] - The company's strategy focuses on creating a value proposition that combines affordable everyday items with larger, more expensive purchases [1] Investment Perspective - The analyst has a long position in Costco shares through stock ownership, options, or other derivatives [2] - The article reflects the analyst's personal opinions and is not influenced by compensation or business relationships with the mentioned company [2] Note: The content does not provide specific financial data, percentage changes, or detailed industry analysis, so those aspects are not included in the summary

Costco's Business Model and Market Presence - Costco operates nearly 900 member-only warehouses across multiple countries, including the US, Canada, Mexico, Australia, and several others [1] - The company attracts millions of customers with its low prices on a wide range of products [1] Valuation and Historical Context - Costco's stock currently trades at over 54 times earnings, a level not seen since April 1999 when its trailing 12-month P/E multiple hit 56.4 [2][3] - In 1999, after reaching this valuation, Costco's share price fell more than 20% within months and later plunged over 40% in 2000 [3] - The current forward earnings multiple of 50.8 and a PEG ratio of 5.5 indicate that the stock remains highly expensive [10] Market Comparisons and Potential Risks - The stock market in 2025 is again expensive, driven by enthusiasm for AI, similar to the dot-com bubble in 1999 [6] - Costco's high valuation is not limited to AI stocks, as it was also an exception in 1999 when many stocks had unjustified valuations [5][11] Growth Prospects and Earnings - Costco reported year-over-year earnings growth of 13% in its latest quarter, which may not be sufficient to justify its high P/E multiple [13] - Unless earnings accelerate significantly, the share price is likely to decline to a level more in line with realistic growth expectations [13][14] Investment Case for Costco - Despite its high valuation, some analysts believe Costco's shares can continue to rise due to its resilient business model and long-term growth opportunities [8][12] - Costco has earned its premium valuation through consistent market-share wins and a stable membership fee-based business model [12] - A potential pullback in the stock price could present an excellent buying opportunity for long-term investors [14]

Zacks Rank and Stock Performance - The Zacks Rank system has a strong track record, with 1 ranked stocks delivering an average annual return of +25% since 1988 [1] - Costco currently holds a Zacks Rank of 3 (Hold) [1] - Costco's stock closed at $936 94, up +1 03% from the previous session, outperforming the S&P 500's daily loss of 1 54% [2] - Over the past month, Costco shares lost 6 17%, underperforming the Retail-Wholesale sector's loss of 4 27% and the S&P 500's loss of 2 2% [2] Earnings and Revenue Estimates - Costco is expected to post an EPS of $4 05 in its upcoming earnings release, representing a 9 16% growth compared to the same quarter last year [3] - Revenue is anticipated to be $62 74 billion, a 7 36% increase from the same quarter last year [3] - For the full year, earnings are projected at $18 01 per share, an 11 79% increase, and revenue at $272 46 billion, a 7 08% increase from the prior year [4] Analyst Estimates and Valuation - Recent upward revisions in analyst estimates reflect positivity towards Costco's business operations and profit generation [5] - Estimate changes are directly correlated with near-term stock prices, and the Zacks Rank system incorporates these changes [6] - Costco has a Forward P/E ratio of 51 5, significantly higher than the industry average of 21 37, indicating a premium valuation [7] - Costco's PEG ratio is 5 54, compared to the industry average of 2 29, suggesting a higher valuation relative to expected earnings growth [8] Industry Overview - The Retail - Discount Stores industry is part of the Retail-Wholesale sector and holds a Zacks Industry Rank of 177, placing it in the bottom 30% of all industries [9] - Industries in the top 50% of the Zacks Industry Rank outperform the bottom half by a factor of 2 to 1 [9]

Company Performance - Costco's stock surged 37 6% over the past year, outperforming the industry (21 8%) and the S&P 500 (25%) [4] - Comparable sales growth was 7 4% in December, following increases of 3 1% and 5 1% in November and October, respectively [2] - Membership fee income grew 7 8% year over year in Q1 fiscal 2025, with paid household memberships up 7 6% and Executive Memberships increasing 9 2% [18] Business Model & Operations - Costco's private-label brand, Kirkland Signature, drives consumer loyalty and repeat business [2] - The company operates on thin margins but high volume due to cost-efficient operations [3] - Membership-based model ensures steady revenue, with renewal rates exceeding 90% in the US and Canada [18] Growth & Expansion - Costco opened six net new warehouses in Q1 fiscal 2025, four of which were outside the US [3] - E-commerce comparable sales grew 13% in Q1, driven by Costco Logistics, which made nearly 1 million deliveries [16] - The US app was downloaded 2 9 million times in Q1, bringing total downloads to approximately 42 million [6][16] Financials & Valuation - Costco's forward 12-month P/E ratio is 49 87, higher than the industry (30 33) and the S&P 500 (22 13) [8] - Zacks Consensus Estimate for EPS increased by 14 and 26 cents for the current and next fiscal years, respectively, indicating expected YoY growth rates of 11 7% and 9 4% [11] Challenges & Risks - SG&A expenses rose 9 1% YoY in the last reported quarter due to higher employee wages and expansion costs [7] - Intense competition from Walmart, BJ's Wholesale Club, and Amazon, which are investing in e-commerce and customer experience [13] - Inflationary pressures are causing consumers to be more judicious with disposable income, affecting merchandise categories [19] Market Sentiment & Investor Considerations - Costco's stock is trading below its 50-day moving average, indicating short-term weakness [20] - Positive estimate revisions highlight strong fundamentals, but high valuation and recent volatility may prompt some investors to book profits [15]

Stock Performance - Costco Wholesale shares surged 38 8% in 2024, driven by strong market performance and expansion of its price-to-earnings (P/E) multiple from 45 to 54 [1][2] - The company's market capitalization exceeded $400 billion, with annual sales reaching $260 billion [1] E-commerce Growth - E-commerce revenue grew 17 1% in the quarter, more than triple the overall revenue growth, highlighting the importance of increasing e-commerce presence to compete with Amazon and Walmart [2] Retail Model and Revenue - Costco's membership-based retail model and bulk pricing strategy have solidified its competitive position, leading to a 5 7% year-over-year revenue growth in Q4 2024 to $94 billion [4] - The US business showed 6% revenue growth, indicating significant potential for global expansion [4] Valuation and Growth Prospects - Costco has historically traded at a premium P/E due to consistent earnings growth and a robust business model, but the current P/E of 54 is close to its 10-year high and well above the 10-year average of 36 [5][6] - With $260 billion in annual sales, rapid growth may be challenging, and a reversion of the P/E to its long-term average could pose risks [6]

Key Takeaways - Oppenheimer analysts maintained an "outperform" rating on Costco Wholesale (COST) following strong December sales performance, citing potential catalysts such as a stock split [1][3] - Costco's adjusted U.S. comparable sales increased nearly 10% year-over-year in December, reinforcing its position as a top pick for analysts [2] - The analysts set a price target of $1,075 per share for Costco, above the consensus estimate of $1,047 from Visible Alpha [2] - Costco's combination of gold bars and a strong gift card assortment continues to resonate with consumers [2] - Costco shares have risen nearly 40% over the past year, closing at $927.37 on Wednesday [2][3] Stock Performance and Catalysts - Costco shares closed at $927.37 on Wednesday, reflecting a 41% increase over the past year [3] - A potential stock split is highlighted as a catalyst for Costco's shares, as high share prices often lead to splits to make them more accessible to retail investors [1][3] Sales and Consumer Appeal - Costco's December sales growth of nearly 10% year-over-year underscores its strong performance in the U.S. market [2] - The company's product offerings, including gold bars and gift cards, continue to attract consumer interest [2]

Sales Performance - Costco reported net sales of $27.52 billion in the five-week period through Jan 5, a 10% year-over-year increase [1] - US comparable sales improved more than 9% year-over-year [1] - E-commerce sales surged 34% year-over-year, with an estimated 15 percentage point boost from the later timing of Thanksgiving/Black Friday/Cyber Monday [1] Analyst Commentary - JPMorgan analysts reiterated an "overweight" rating but lowered price target to $1,065 from $1,090 [1] - Visible Alpha analyst consensus price target is $1,047.06 [1] - Citi analysts expect "modest strength" in Costco stock following December results, maintaining a "neutral" rating and $1,060 price target [2][3] Market Context - Costco shares closed at $927.37 on Wednesday, representing a roughly 15% discount to JPMorgan's price target [1] - Shares have fallen 7% since hitting an all-time closing high of $994.69 on Dec 11 [2] - Results indicate improving consumer spending, particularly among upper-middle class and higher-income consumers [2]

Costco's Sales Performance - Costco's comparable sales in the US, excluding gasoline prices and foreign exchange rates, increased by 9.8% in December, while Canada and Other International markets saw gains of 10.3% and 9.8%, respectively [1] - Total comparable sales, excluding external factors, rose by 9.9% [1] - For the five weeks ended Jan 5, comparable sales in the US grew by 9.3%, with Canada and Other International markets increasing by 4.3% and 1%, respectively [7] - Total company comparable sales for December rose by 7.4%, following consecutive increases of 3.1% and 5.1% in November and October [7] - Costco's e-commerce comparable sales surged by 34.4%, or 35.7% when adjusted for gasoline prices and foreign exchange fluctuations [8] - E-commerce sales were positively impacted by approximately 15 percentage points due to the timing of Thanksgiving, Black Friday, and Cyber Monday [8] - Net sales for December increased by 9.9%, reaching $27.52 billion, up from $25.03 billion in the same period last year [9] Costco's Business Model and Market Position - Costco's membership-based structure and high renewal rates are key growth drivers, ensuring customer loyalty and competitive pricing [10] - The company's efficient supply chain management and bulk purchasing power contribute to its operational excellence [10] - Shares of Costco have advanced by 37.8% in the past year, outperforming the Retail – Discount Stores industry's rise of 21.9% [10] Investment Opportunities in Related Companies - Freshpet Inc (FRPT) has a trailing four-quarter earnings surprise of 144.5% on average, with current financial-year sales and earnings expected to grow by 27.2% and 228.6%, respectively [3] - United Natural Foods (UNFI) has a trailing four-quarter earnings surprise of 553.1% on average, with current financial-year sales and earnings projected to grow by 0.3% and 442.9%, respectively [4] - Sprouts Farmers (SFM) has a trailing four-quarter earnings surprise of 15.3% on average, with current financial-year sales and earnings expected to grow by 12.2% and 29.6%, respectively [5]

About the Publisher - Proactive provides fast, accessible, and actionable business and finance news content to a global investment audience [2] - The company's content is produced independently by experienced and qualified teams of news journalists [2] - Proactive has bureaus and studios in key finance and investment hubs including London, New York, Toronto, Vancouver, Sydney, and Perth [2] Market Expertise - The company specializes in medium and small-cap markets while also covering blue-chip companies, commodities, and broader investment stories [3] - Proactive delivers news and unique insights across various sectors including biotech and pharma, mining and natural resources, battery metals, oil and gas, crypto, and emerging digital and EV technologies [3] Technology Adoption - Proactive is a forward-looking and enthusiastic adopter of technology [4] - The company's human content creators are equipped with decades of expertise and experience, and they use technology to assist and enhance workflows [4] - Proactive occasionally uses automation and software tools, including generative AI, but all content is edited and authored by humans in line with best practices for content production and SEO [5]